Erica Statham and Dr Penny Hebgin-Barnes1
Withcote Chapel, Leicestershire, was built as the chapel of the adjacent Withcote Hall.2 It now belongs to the Churches Conservation Trust and is open daily. Its glazing is generally considered to be a rare survival of pre-Reformation glass presented in a largely comprehensible scheme. However, there are several problems with this idea once the glass is examined in detail, and the following article intends to address some of those issues.

The building of the chapel was begun around 1500 by Katherine Smith, maiden name Ashby, and her first husband William Smith (d.1506) and completed by Katherine and her second husband Roger Ratcliffe (d.c.1537), the owners of Withcote Hall. It is a freestanding rectangular building consisting of four bays with the nave and chancel undifferentiated and an embattled parapet with tall pinnacles at each corner. The north and south sides both have four square-headed windows each of three round-headed lights. There are no east or west windows (Fig. 1). The interior fittings, which date from a refurbishment in c.1744, include a large wooden reredos at the east end.3
A number of documents exist relating to the chapel’s glazing. William Burton, a Leicestershire historian, made observations during the 17th century, but the most useful source is another Leicestershire historian John Nichols, whose work spanned the late 18th and early 19th centuries.4 In 1910 Sir E. G. B. Palmer, the then owner of the hall and chapel, called in the firm of James Powell and Sons to remove and relead the glass.5 Palmer appears to have been unhappy with Powell’s reglazing and in 1919 he engaged the expert Gordon Rushforth, who reported his findings in an unpublished letter.6 In 1939 Christopher Woodforde published an article in the Burlington Magazine which heavily influenced all subsequent accounts of the Withcote glazing.7 In 1955 a description of the chapel and its glazing by A.R. Dufty appeared in the Archaeological Journal.8 Barley Studio did some work in 1988 after the Churches Conservation Trust had acquired the chapel, but this was largely protective glazing.9
The glazing now in the chapel windows can be divided into 3 separate groups. The first and largest group consists of 18 full-length standing figures identified by Latin inscriptions who occupy all the lights of the three easternmost windows on both sides of the chapel.10 Eight of these figures represent apostles, Jesus’ 12 disciples without Judas, who is usually replaced by either Matthias or Paul (Fig. 2). Each holds a blackletter scroll bearing his line in Latin from the Apostles’ Creed, has a halo or nimbus and carries a recognisable emblem, for example Andrew carries his saltire and Peter a set of keys, both illustrated here at Withcote (Fig. 3). The four missing here are Matthew, Matthias, James the Greater and Simon the Zealot, but they must have existed originally and there are odd words scattered about that could relate to them.
The remaining figures represent Old Testament prophets bearing scrolls (Figs. 4 and 5). The prophets wear exotic garments and hats and have been harder to distinguish as there are many more prophets in the Old Testament than there are corresponding apostles and the medieval glaziers did not always use the same characters. To some extent it is possible to identify them through the prophecies whose words are inscribed on their scrolls.11 From the east end they appear to be Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, Daniel, Hosea, Joel, Amos (with the label ‘david’), Micah and Zephaniah (or it might be Malachi, as his text is from Malachi.) Finally Zechariah is now to be found on the north side with the apostles (Fig. 6). Thus, two prophets have gone astray if the usual scheme was adhered to. The label beneath Amos suggests that one must have been David, although he was a king of Israel rather than a prophet. The final missing prophet was perhaps Obadiah.12
All the figures stand beneath architectural canopies in an extravagant Renaissance style composed of elements including squat bulbous columns, putti, masks, cornucopiae, foliage and hybrid creatures. Each canopy top incorporates a large heraldic device surmounted by a closed crown: the royal arms of England in each central light flanked in each outer light by a royal badge of either a fleur-de-lis, a portcullis, or a red or Tudor rose (Figs 2 and 3).
It is clear that this scheme originally filled all 8 windows of the chapel, with 12 apostles on one side and 12 prophets on the other. The pairing of the Apostles’ Creed with the Prophets’ Creed was an established tradition in medieval art, the best-known example of which is found in six windows dating from c.1500-15 at St Mary’s church, Fairford (Gloucestershire)13 (Figs. 7 and 8). At Withcote this type/anti-type scenario is aptly illustrated by the prophet Joel whose prophecy is “I will pour out my Spirit” (Fig. 4) and in the opposite window St Bartholomew, whose line from the Apostles’ Creed is “I believe in the Holy Spirit” (Fig. 2). However, this is the only duo that is remotely correct. The extent of the rearrangement is greater than previously supposed. All but one of the prophets are on the south side and all the apostles are on the north. According to medieval typology the prophets should be on the darker north side, symbolising the darkness that prevailed until Christ brought light into the world, as symbolised by his apostles on the lighter south side. This is the traditional arrangement that is found at Fairford and it seems unlikely that it was reversed at Withcote.14
Further evidence of reordering is provided by Nichols who saw 18 figures in the 6 easternmost windows. He recorded inscriptions naming three apostles (Philip, Bartholomew, Thomas) and three prophets (David, Joel and Ozias, i.e. Hosea) in the south windows, and four apostles (Andrew, Peter, James the Great and Simon) and two prophets (Daniel and Micah) in the north windows.15 Of all these figures, only St Andrew (Fig. 3) now remains in the same window and since this is on the north side he is probably not in situ. Powell’s Order Book lists all the figures in their present positions, so they must have been rearranged between Nichols’ visit and 1910. Sadly, it is clear that the original scheme, which filled all 12 lights on either side, does not appear to have been particularly sensitively or accurately restored.

The second group of glass is the heraldry in the westernmost north and south windows. The north window contains the royal arms, an armorial of Ratcliffe alone and another of Ratcliffe impaling Ashby, two closed crowns, two Tudor roses and the badge of a phoenix rising from a flowering mound within a castle surmounted by a closed crown (Fig. 9). This was the emblem of Henry VIII’s third queen Jane Seymour, and on the basis of it Woodforde assigned the chapel’s whole glazing scheme to the period between her marriage in May 1536 and her death in October 1537. However, it is obvious that Jane’s badge was not part of the original scheme. It does not fit the pattern of the remaining canopies in which the royal arms of England are flanked by the royal badges of roses, portcullises or fleurs-de-lis, and it is set within a chaplet unlike any of their surrounds. Moreover, it was seen by Nichols in the bow window of a small room in Withcote Hall, along with the two Ratcliffe shields16 and the royal arms that now surround it, so this glass was evidently moved from the hall to its present position in the north window of the chapel at an unknown date after Nichols’ visit.17 This removes the reason for dating the Withcote glazing scheme to 1536-7.
Jane’s badge may not even have originated in Withcote Hall. The hall is an 18th-century building that replaced an earlier one belonging to the Smiths and Ratcliffes and its occupants might well have obtained glass from elsewhere, whilst also reusing old glass, including 16th-century family armorials from the previous building. In his letter Rushforth noted “As there is a similar badge of Jane Seymour in the East window of Launde chapel – no doubt put there by Thomas Cromwell, who was at the height of his prosperity while Jane was Queen (1536,37) – I expect they all came from Launde at some time or other, & in recent times have been put into the church.” Gregory Cromwell, son of Thomas, is buried in the chapel at Launde. He inherited Launde Abbey from his father and was married to Elizabeth Seymour, the sister of Jane.18 They lived at Launde from 1540 until Gregory’s death in 1551, near neighbours to Katherine and Roger Ratcliffe. Roger would have known Jane Seymour at court since they both served Queen Katherine of Aragon, and he may have remained on good terms with Jane until her death in 1537, and then by association with her sister Elizabeth. At some unspecified date some of the glass from Launde Abbey might have found its way to Withcote as Rushforth suggested.19
The westernmost south window of Withcote chapel contains the royal arms of England, a closed crown, the badges of a white rose and a Tudor rose and two armorials of Ratcliffe, one impaling Ashby and the other impaling Smith. These two Ratcliffe armorials were seen in this window by Nichols along with two others that have since vanished. They originated in the chapel, as described by Roger Smith in 1632: “the windows being all alike enriched with large proportions of all the Apostles and some of the Prophets; and under every of them the several pictures and arms, in coloured glass, of my great grandfathers William Smith and Roger Ratcliffe, and of my great grandmother Ashby, wife unto them both; and also of my grandfather John Smith, and, Dorothy his wife, my grandmother, with their several coats; wherein my great grandfather Smith and his wife are ranked in the first place.”20 Nichols’ description of the chapel confirmed that some of these armorials remained in the bottom panels of windows beneath the holy figures, but all have now disappeared apart from the two that were already in the westernmost south window when Nichols saw them and the remnants of others now gathered in the panel beneath St Philip along with fragments of donors (Fig. 2). Comparison with other 16th-century windows containing donors suggests that the most likely layout of the lower rows of panels described by Roger Smith would place the husband in the left light and the wife in the right, both kneeling and facing inwards towards their armorial in the central light, although it is possible that in a unified scheme such as this all the donors faced towards the east end, with the wife kneeling behind the husband. The fragments of donors confirm that the couples knelt at prayer desks with open books on them and wore garments or armour emblasoned with their shields.21
The armorials listed by the antiquarians confirm that the windows were glazed by the Smith and Ratcliffe families who had built the chapel. It has hitherto been assumed that the donors were Roger Ratcliffe and his wife Katherine on the grounds that the only four armorials to survive are all of Ratcliffe, and Roger’s death in c.1537 coincided with the display of Queen Jane Seymour’s badge. In his will dated September 1536 and proved in February 1538 Roger left altar cloths, vestments, silver and silver-gilt pyxes to Withcote chapel but made no bequest for glazing.22 This might indicate that the glazing was already in place, or at least paid for, but it is not conclusive evidence. However, the inclusion amongst the donors of John Smith (d.1545) and his wife Dorothy Cave, and the fact that John’s parents William and Katherine Smith were ranked in first place, raises other possibilities. John and Dorothy might have donated the glazing after inheriting Withcote on Roger Ratcliffe’s death to commemorate either their predecessors’ construction of the chapel or the return of Withcote to the Smith family after the Ratcliffe interlude. Alternatively, the glazing might have been donated jointly by the Ratcliffes who held Withcote and the Smiths who would succeed them.
The third group of glass consists of 6 small rectangular early 16th-century panels in the bottom row of the easternmost window on each side. The 3 panels in the north window depict Christ crucified between the 2 thieves (Fig. 3). Those in the south window depict a figure of the Virgin Mary between St John the Evangelist on the right (this panel was stolen in 2016 and has never been recovered23) and a composite panel of fragments included a bearded head on the left (this whole light is now boarded up). Woodforde suggested that these figures originated in the lower rows of the chapel windows, but Nichols saw them in the hall in the same bow window as Jane Seymour’s badge and the accompanying armorials. Nichols thought that the small room containing these panels was formerly a private oratory.24 Elizabeth Johnson, who inherited Withcote in 1742 and was probably responsible for the refurbishment of the chapel, was high church and might have acquired these religious subjects for her own devotions. They are not English and did not form part of the chapel’s original glazing.
Woodforde proposed that the chapel’s glazing scheme was the work of Galyon Hone and his team: “The constant use of royal arms and badges and the fine technique and richness of the glass all go to suggest very strongly that these windows were the work of the King’s own glazier and his assistants.”25 Galyon Hone, who held the office of King’s Glazier from c.1520 until 1550, was the leader of a group of Netherlandish glaziers living in Southwark. The reigns of Henry VII and Henry VIII saw an influx of these accomplished foreigners whose style, characterised by animated and realistic figures, detailed background settings and Renaissance architectural forms, made the native English glaziers’ work appear old-fashioned. By the time Hone became King’s Glazier all the most prestigious projects commissioned by Henry VIII and his wealthy subjects were being awarded to Netherlandish glaziers.26 Roger Ratcliffe’s court connections would doubtless have introduced him to Hone’s work and perhaps to the man himself. One objection to Hone’s involvement with the Withcote glazing that can now be dismissed is that he was occupied working on royal projects throughout the period when Jane Seymour was queen (not least in replacing Anne Boleyn’s badges with Jane’s in the windows of royal residences!). The removal of the narrow dating band of 1536-7 opens up a much longer period during which his workshop could have worked for private clients in lulls between royal commissions.
Hone worked for the king at many sites including King’s College Chapel, Cambridge, York Place, Westminster Palace, Hampton Court, Windsor Castle, St James’ Palace and many former monastic buildings acquired by the Crown at the Dissolution and redecorated for the king’s use.27 The only one of these schemes to survive is King’s College Chapel. In 1526 Hone, James Nicholson, Richard Bond and Thomas Reve were contracted to glaze 18 of its 26 great windows within 5 years, but at least 10 were not glazed until 1535-47.28 In his study of the King’s College Chapel windows Wayment tentatively identified different hands with the individual glaziers named in the contract.29 Richard Marks concluded more cautiously that it was not possible to attribute any particular window or panel to any of the glaziers named in the contract, nor even to differentiate between the work of the Netherlanders Hone and Nicholson and the Englishmen Bond and Reve who had absorbed their style and techniques.30
The Withcote glazing is in the style of King’s College. At both sites the top parts of the windows are filled with crowned royal badges including fleurs-de-lis, roses and portcullises. Comparison of the figures reveals similarities including thick wavy hair and beards, sometimes ending in curls and sometimes painted dark brown on a stippled base, bulbous noses and thick lips sometimes slightly parted to reveal bared teeth. Wayment’s study acknowledged the stylistic links between Withcote, King’s College and Fairford but stated that Hone’s hand was not to be distinguished with certainty at Withcote. It also noted that the work of the assistant to the unidentified master glazier responsible for window 24 at King’s College resembled that of one of the Withcote glaziers.31 This similarity can be seen in the second and fourth messengers in window 24 (Figs. 10 and 11). Thus, the Withcote glazing cannot definitely be assigned to Hone’s workshop and must be grouped with the other instances of glazing in this style, which Wayment termed the ‘Southwark school’, that survive at many locations throughout England.32
A rich and varied colour palette is used at both King’s College and Withcote, although a greater proportion of white glass is found at the latter, largely due to the canopies. This highlights a major difference between the Withcote scheme of individuals standing beneath canopies and the King’s College windows which depict narrative scenes in landscape settings without canopies spread across two or more lights.
A closer parallel to Withcote formerly existed in the chapel of Hampton Court Palace, probably glazed by James Nicholson who was employed at various other sites by its donor Cardinal Wolsey. This lost scheme is known from rather sketchy workshop copies of 24 vidimuses prepared for Wolsey circa 1525-26.33 One shows a 4-light window containing the prophets Jeremiah, David, Isaiah and Zechariah accompanied by curling scrolls and wearing elaborate headgear and garments including puffed sleeves and dangling tassels. They stand beneath canopies composed of Renaissance elements including arches decorated with roundels, putti and cornucopiae (Fig. 12).34 All these features are found in the Withcote glazing. Three other vidimuses show the twelve apostles beneath canopies (Fig. 13).35 These vidimuses are not the models for the Withcote series but they confirm that similar windows were being produced in the 1520s. Roger Ratcliffe would probably have seen the apostle and prophet windows in the Hampton Court chapel and they might have inspired him to commission the Withcote glazing; if so, it could date from as early as the late 1520s.


One other theory about the Withcote glazing must be rejected. It has sometimes been suggested that it is too fine for a small country church and that it must therefore have originated in another grander building such as the Hampton Court chapel.36 It is true that after the dissolution of the monasteries in 1536-40 some monastic glazing was purchased and installed in parish churches37 and that John Smith would have been able to procure glazing from dissolved monastic houses through his brother-in-law Francis Cave who was a church commissioner. However the original Withcote glazing scheme of 24 individual lights would have fitted the chapel windows perfectly and the donors described by Roger Smith show that it was commissioned for the chapel.
In conclusion Withcote is a fine if incomplete example of an early 16th-century scheme executed in the latest style by unnamed foreign glaziers and derived from windows on the same theme in grander buildings. Although its subject of the Apostles’ and Prophets’ Creeds was a late-medieval concept it was entirely in keeping with the emerging English Reformation’s emphasis on biblical sources. Dating from the latter half of Henry VIII’s reign it loyally proclaimed his sovereignty, but it cannot be associated with any of his wives.
Footnotes
- The authors would like to thank Christopher Parkinson and Professor Lisa Reilly for the use of their images and for assistance with this article, and the Musées royaux d’Art et d’Histoire, Brussels, for permission to reproduce figs 12 and 13.[↩]
- Although it was the parish church it resembles contemporary domestic chapels.[↩]
- Historic England, Official List Entry for Withcote Chapel, https://historicengland.org.uk/listing/the-list/list-entry/1074845[↩]
- J. Nichols, The History and Antiquities of the County of Leicester, vol. II part I, London, 1795, p.392; vol III part I, London, 1800, pp.520, 526. Nichols quotes both Burton and John Leland who admired the newly-built house but did not mention the chapel[↩]
- Recorded in Powell’s Order Book, order no. 2382 (now in the V & A , kindly photocopied by the archivist).[↩]
- G. McN. Rushforth, letter to Sir Geoffrey Palmer dated 30th September 1919, in the Churches Conservation Trust archive.[↩]
- C. Woodforde, ‘The Painted Glass in Withcote Church’, Burlington Magazine vol. 75, no. 436, July 1939, pp.17-22.[↩]
- A.R. Dufty, ‘Withcote Chapel’, Archaeological Journal vol. CXII, 1955, pp.178-81 (available online: https://doi.org/10.5284/1018054 ). [↩]
- Images of the glass taken during conservation at Barley Studio are available in the CVMA picture archive: https://archaeologydataservice.ac.uk/archives/collections/view/1006150/results.cfm?locationKey=73[↩]
- Only 17 figures are visible as the eastern light of the easternmost south window containing the figure of Isaiah is currently boarded up. This is due to clay shrinkage causing structural damage to the east end of the chapel including large cracks in the stonework of this light, resulting in the removal of the glass for its protection.[↩]
- All 18 figures are listed and their scrolls and inscriptions transcribed in Woodforde, Painted Glass, p.18 and Dufty, ‘Withcote Chapel’, pp.180-81.[↩]
- Both David and Obadiah appear in the complete Prophets’ Creed series at Fairford along with the same 10 prophets who survive at Withcote (S. Brown & L. MacDonald (eds), The Medieval Stained Glass of Fairford Parish Church , Stroud, 1997, pls. 18-20.) [↩]
- Brown & MacDonald, Fairford, pp.62-3, pls.10-12, 18-20.[↩]
- Rushforth wrote in his letter that ‘the Apostles probably filled the windows on the north side i.e. the Gospel side, a place of honour to the right of the altar’, but the south side is to the right of the altar.[↩]
- Nichols, Leicester, vol. II part I, p.392. Nichols named two of the figures in a south window as ‘Simeon’ and ‘St Christopher’, but this must have been an error.[↩]
- These Ratcliffe shields are from the same series as the two now in the opposite south window, suggesting that all 4 shields originated in the chapel windows but 2 were moved to the hall before Nichols’ visit and back again after it.[↩]
- Nichols saw two armorials of England and ‘the rose with regal crown, &c.’ in this window of the chapel (Leicester, vol. II part I, p.392).[↩]
- The complete peerage of England, Scotland, Ireland, Great Britain, and the United Kingdom, vol. III, London, 1913, pp. 557-58.[↩]
- In his letter Rushforth expressed an intention to return to Withcote to investigate further but added that he might be too busy due to the replacement of the glass in Malvern Priory church. The latter would result in the publication of his magnum opus Medieval Christian Imagery in 1936 but unfortunately it also meant that he never revisited Withcote. If he had published his findings the incorrect dating of the glass to 1536-7 by later authors could have been avoided.[↩]
- Letter from Roger Smith to William Burton dated 16th October 1632, quoted in Nichols, Leicester, vol. III part I, p.520. Spelling modernised.[↩]
- Part of a desk with a book is now set amongst other fragments in the panel beneath Hosea.[↩]
- Dufty, ‘Withcote Chapel’, p.179.[↩]
- The theft was reported in Vidimus no. 102 where the stolen panel was incorrectly described as depicting the prophet Ezekiel (https://www.vidimus.org/news/theft-of-renaissance-glass/ ).[↩]
- Woodforde, Painted Glass, p.21; Nichols, Leicester, vol. II part I, p.392.[↩]
- Woodforde, Painted Glass, p.21.[↩]
- R. Marks, Stained Glass in England During the Middle Ages, London/Toronto,1993, pp.205-19; Carola Hicks, The King’s Glass: A Story of Tudor Power and Secret Art, London, 2007, pp. 67-85. The resulting antagonism between the English Glaziers’ Company whose jurisdiction was confined to London and the Netherlandish glaziers in Southwark which was outside the city’s boundary is described in Hicks, King’s Glass, pp.144-47, 189-94.[↩]
- Marks, Stained Glass, p.207; H. Wayment, The Windows of King’s College Chapel, Cambridge CVMA GB, Supplementary Vol. I, London, 1972, pp.12-13.[↩]
- Marks Stained Glass p.217; Wayment, Windows, pp. 4, 123-24. At the same time 2 other glaziers Francis Williamson and Simon Symondes were contracted to glaze 4 more windows of the chapel. For the King’s College windows see Wayment, Windows and King’s College Chapel Cambridge: The Great Windows. Introduction and Guide, Cambridge, 1982.[↩]
- Wayment, Windows, pp. xxxi, 22-29.[↩]
- Marks, Stained Glass, p.217.[↩]
- Wayment, Windows, pp.13 n.3, 107. Window 24 depicts the death and funeral of the Virgin Mary, the death of Tobit and the funeral of Jacob. Wayment believes that its execution was subcontracted by the glaziers Williamson and Symondes to another glazier (Wayment, Windows, pp.107-09 and King’s College, pp. 60-61).[↩]
- Wayment, Windows, p.11 lists 20 sites with glass in this style and Marks, Stained Glass, pp. 222-25 adds several more.[↩]
- H. Wayment, ‘Twenty-Four Vidimuses for Cardinal Wolsey’, Master Drawings, 1985/1986, Vol. 23/24, No. 4, 1985/1986, pp. 503-517 & pp.569-587. The vidimuses are annotated in the hand of an Anglo-Netherlandish glazier. Wayment attributed them on stylistic grounds to the workshop of Erhard Schön of Nuremberg.[↩]
- Wayment, ‘Vidimuses’, pl.19.[↩]
- Wayment, ‘Vidimuses’, pls.12-14.[↩]
- The chaplain from Hampton Court suggested that the Withcote glass came from the chapel there in a lecture given on behalf of the Churches Conservation Trust attended by Erica Statham.[↩]
- Marks, Stained Glass, p.230; H. Willmott, ‘Glaziers and the removal, recycling and replacement of windows during the Reformation in England’, Church Archaeology, Vol. 19, 2019 for 2015, pp. 45 -52.[↩]










